How color changes the way we read parking occupancy maps

Cars parked along the oceanfront at Yachats State Park, Oregon.

How do color choices affect the way we perceive data? It’s a question I’ve been asking for the 15 years I’ve been making parking occupancy maps. The familiar green-to-yellow-to-red heat map is often a good answer. Municipal clients expect it, residents can digest it without knowing the ins and outs of parking management, and red draws attention to places that may be too full and need some help. There are good reasons that convention has stuck around.

But those colors also carry a value judgment: red is bad, green is good. Overfull parking certainly creates problems, but vastly underused parking represents an opportunity cost too. And a management target of, say, 70–85% occupancy can land in the orange “uh-oh” range on a traditional heat map, even though that’s where we want to be. This is why Evan Manvel made the case for a simple saturation scale when we were working on Oregon’s Parking Management Jump Start Guide. Less parking use, less color; more parking use, more color. It may take a moment to read the legend, but that pause can be useful. You’re asking what the map means rather than immediately reacting to red. Our Yachats and Wilsonville maps are examples of this approach: lighter shades for less use, deeper shades for more, without an automatic good-or-bad verdict.

There are good reasons to use either approach. It depends on the context, the audience, and what you’re trying to show. The important thing is to think about those choices and have a reason for them. As we develop the data visualizer for our Analytics Atlas, I want people to be able to switch between both views and see how the presentation changes their reading of the same data.

I started in graphic design before going into urban planning, so I find this intersection particularly fascinating. How we present information is part of how we make sense of it.

Share this